Book Review: Brinkman & van der Vlugt Architects

van nelle fabriek

The Dutch modernists architectural practice Brinkman & van der Vlugt is mostly known for the Van Nelle factory (1925-1931). This building is an excellent example of New Objectivity architecture (Neue Sachlichkeit), and its quality is, in my mind, on par with the Bauhaus building in Dessau by Walter Gropius. As a matter of fact, the director of the Van Nelle company at the time; C.H. van der Leeuw, was a visionary figure who traveled extensively and befriended many avant-garde architects. He corresponded with Gropius, Richard Neutra, and many others and traveled to the United States in preparation for the building of the factory.  When he met Neutra, he decided to sponsor the building of his private house with an interest free loan, which later became known as VDL  research house (acronym of Van der Leeuw). He was, apart from his interest in the avant-garde, also a key figure and patron of the international Theosophical Society, where he met Annie Besant and Krishnamurti.

Due to the strong association of the architectural office with the Van Nelle factory, the architects Brinkman & van der Vlugt are sometimes understood as commercial architects who were serving their clients’ needs rather than being innovative figures by and of themselves. They were, in short, somewhat overshadowed by the influential Kees van der Leeuw. Given the fact that in 1922 Van der Vlugt had already done a modernist school in Groningen, (with J.G. Wiebenga), and that Brinkman designed the iconic Spangen housing block with so called ‘streets in the sky’ in the same year, (which later influenced the Smithsons), this reading of history is in serious need of correction. Most of the original literary sources on Dutch modernism are in Dutch, German and French language publications, which makes an English language monograph, in theory at least, welcome. It is quite unfortunate, however, that the architecture is continuously described in the book as “International Style”, – which is the reductive and unfortunate positioning of European modernism as a ‘style’-, and that the commercial rather than the creative and artistic influences are predominantly traced in this book. The sources for the architecture of the office of Brinkman & van der Vlugt are, in fact, much more wide-ranging and complex, and it is quite difficult to maintain, given the unmarketable reputation of the New Objectivity and the economic crisis of 1929, that commercial motives were the main driver of this innovative practice.

For a better account of the architecture of the office I would rather refer you to Dutch language sources, but for those who are not fluent in Dutch, the book does form a nice first introduction to the variety of the work of these important architects.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

About thomaswensing

Architect and Activist. Over the years I have become increasingly aware that I need to actively engage with the issues I care about. My passions and irritations are many and change often, but a red thread is always a deep concern over the fact that capitalism does not work as it is claimed it does, democracies only serve the needs of the few and environmental resource depletion and pressures continue to mount. I think it is time for citizen's activism to create pressure, to bang on the doors of established powers and interests until we get it right. As you will notice, if you continue to follow my blog over time, there are certain fetishes I have; modernism, social housing, the avant-garde. I propose to recuperate the Modern Project from the dustbin of history and re-establish the link between social engagement and architecture. Watch it all come down needs to be followed by let the good stuff blossom!

3 responses to “Book Review: Brinkman & van der Vlugt Architects”

  1. e blits says :

    I just read your instructive text.
    just one minor comment: Hotel American, in Amsterdam, was not build by de Bazel, but by Willem Kromhout (1898-1902)

    • thomaswensing says :

      Hi, I have changed the text and omitted the mention of Hotel American, you were absolutely right. I sometimes rely too much on my memory without double-checking – thanks for pointing it out.
      Best, Thomas

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Raymond Neutra on the VDL Research house | thomaswensing - 2013/06/20

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: